In recent years, increasing attention has been drawn to the problems associated with economic systems that concentrate wealth and resources in the hands of a few. These systems, whether capitalist, socialist, or a hybrid of the two, often result in social inequality, environmental degradation, and various forms of oppression. For individuals and communities seeking an alternative, a set of principles and practices rooted in the concept of distributism has emerged as a compelling solution.
From the Orthodox Christian perspective, the essence of distributism aligns significantly with the faith’s teachings on social ethics. Orthodox Christianity, in its rich tradition and teaching, has always emphasized the value of every human being, the importance of community, and a call for justice and love in economic affairs. The faith encourages a balanced approach to material wealth – one that avoids the extremes of indulgence on one hand and neglect on the other. The call for economic justice and care for the poor is central to Orthodox social teaching, as is the recognition of the inherent dignity and worth of every person.
At the core of distributism is the belief that ownership and control of the means of production should be as widespread as possible. Instead of wealth and power being concentrated in the hands of a few – whether those few are elites in a capitalist economy, or state officials in a socialist one – they should be spread out among the many. In line with Orthodox Christianity, distributism emphasizes the importance of community, cooperation, and care for the poor and the planet.
Distributism fosters an economy where families and communities can thrive, small businesses are supported, the earth is cared for, and individuals can live in dignity and peace. This aligns closely with Orthodox teachings about the stewardship of creation, the value of work, and the importance of community.
In this essay, we will explore in-depth the principles of subsidiarity, micro-banking networks that do not use interest, micro-farming networks, permaculture, rejection of financialization, distributed cash for service and charitable medical clinics, parochial schools and homeschooling networks, parish communities, and an increase in “the commons”. We will delve into how these principles relate to Orthodox Christian values, the challenges they face, and how the Knights Hospitaller Initiative (KHI) is working to help communities implement these practices for a more peaceful, resilient future.
Absolutely! Let’s delve deeper into each topic and provide references where applicable.
1. Subsidiarity and Peace
Subsidiarity is a principle that originated in Catholic social teaching, but it has broad application in various forms of social governance. It emphasizes that decisions should be made as closely as possible to the level where they will have their effect, ideally at the local or community level. This principle promotes participation, autonomy, and a sense of agency among individuals within a community.
When people are involved in making decisions that directly impact them, they are more likely to take ownership and feel empowered, leading to deeper investment in their communities. This can promote cooperation, mutual understanding, and community spirit, which are key ingredients for a peaceful society. Also, subsidiarity could potentially mitigate power imbalances, as power is distributed more evenly at the grassroots level rather than being concentrated at the top.
By fostering a sense of shared responsibility and collective problem-solving, subsidiarity can help to build resilience within communities and reduce conflict, promoting more harmonious and peaceful social environments.
2. Micro-Banking Networks and Peace
Microfinance, particularly the no-interest micro-banking model, has long been hailed as a tool for poverty alleviation, women’s empowerment, and small-scale entrepreneurship. Access to finance can stimulate local economies, create jobs, and help lift individuals and communities out of poverty. When people are less worried about basic survival, tensions can decrease, and societies can become more peaceful.
Moreover, micro-banking that is free of interest prevents the undue burden of debt that often accompanies traditional loan structures, reducing the financial stress on borrowers. It is also worth noting that these micro-banking networks often encourage group lending or involve community-based structures that foster collective responsibility and community solidarity.
Microfinance programs that promote social cohesion and build community resilience could contribute to conflict prevention and peacebuilding. Through their community-centric operations, micro-banking networks have the potential to contribute to peacebuilding by improving livelihoods, empowering marginalized groups, and facilitating social cohesion.
3. Micro-Farming Networks, Permaculture, and Peace
Micro-farming networks, where small-scale farms collaborate to share resources and knowledge, have significant potential to increase self-sufficiency, food security, and community resilience. By emphasizing sustainable and regenerative agricultural practices, micro-farming can help foster strong connections to the land, support local economies, and protect the environment.
Permaculture, a set of design principles centered on whole systems thinking, simulating, or directly utilizing the patterns and resilient features observed in natural ecosystems, fits well into this scenario. Permaculture practices on a micro-farm can increase productivity, improve soil health, promote biodiversity, and make farms more resilient to climate change and other external shocks.
These practices can indirectly contribute to peace by addressing some of the root causes of conflict, such as resource scarcity and economic instability. When communities are self-sufficient and food secure, they are less likely to experience tensions that can lead to violence. The cooperative nature of micro-farming networks can also promote social cohesion, mutual trust, and a shared sense of purpose – all of which are critical components of peacebuilding.
Moreover, the fact that micro-farming and permaculture often involve a strong element of community engagement and participation means that they can play a significant role in peacebuilding at the community level.
4. Rejection of Financialization and Its Impacts
Financialization, the increasing role of financial markets, financial motives, financial institutions, and financial elites in the operation of the economy and its governing institutions, both at the national and international levels, has been critiqued for its association with income inequality, economic instability, and the undermining of productive sectors.
When the financial sector becomes too dominant, it can distort economic priorities, lead to speculative bubbles, and contribute to economic crises[. Moreover, financialization can deepen socio-economic divisions by rewarding those with financial assets and penalizing those who depend on wages for their income.
Rejecting financialization, then, can serve to level the economic playing field and foster greater economic stability. It can lead to an emphasis on productive, rather than speculative, economic activities and can help ensure that economic benefits are more evenly distributed.
KHI can contribute to this by supporting economic activities that are grounded in real goods and services and that directly benefit communities. It can also help communities navigate away from dependency on speculative financial systems by providing financial education and promoting alternative economic models.
5. Distributed Cash for Service and Charitable Medical Clinics
In many parts of the world, access to healthcare is far from universal. This is due in part to the high cost of medical services and the lack of infrastructure in some areas. A model that prioritizes local, distributed cash-for-service and charitable medical clinics can potentially fill this gap.
Distributed cash for service implies that payments are made directly to healthcare providers for the services they offer, rather than through insurance. This model can increase transparency and potentially lower costs by eliminating the overhead and complexity of insurance. Charitable medical clinics provide free or low-cost care to those who can’t afford it, funded by donations and grants.
By helping establish and support these types of healthcare models, Knights Hospitaller International (OBS) can directly contribute to improving access to health services. This approach aligns with the principles of subsidiarity and distributism, as it emphasizes local control and direct service provision. Moreover, it can foster community resilience and solidarity, as individuals come together to ensure that everyone in the community has access to the care they need.
6. Parochial Schools and Homeschooling Networks
Education is another area where centralization has often led to unequal outcomes and a lack of local control. Parochial schools and homeschooling networks present a viable alternative that aligns with the principles of subsidiarity and distributism.
Parochial schools, which are usually affiliated with a religious organization, can offer high-quality education that also instills specific moral and religious values. They typically operate at a local level and are responsive to the needs and values of the community.
Homeschooling networks take this a step further by providing a highly personalized educational experience. These networks allow families to collaborate and share resources, while still tailoring the education to the specific needs and values of each child[^18^].
By supporting the development of parochial schools and homeschooling networks, Knights Hospitaller International (OBS) can help ensure that education is both high-quality and locally controlled. Moreover, these types of educational models can help strengthen community ties and promote a sense of shared responsibility for the well-being of the community’s children.
7. Parish Communities and Increase in “The Commons”
Parish communities and shared public resources, or “the commons”, offer another path toward decentralization, community empowerment, and peace. A parish, in the religious sense, is a local church community of the Christian Church[^19^]. Parishes serve not only as places of worship but also as centers of community life. They can provide various social services, support networks, and a sense of identity and belonging.
Increasing “the commons” refers to the expansion of shared resources that a community manages for collective benefit. This can include physical resources like parks, libraries, or community gardens, as well as intangible resources like community knowledge or cultural heritage. A commons-based approach can foster mutual responsibility, shared stewardship, and community resilience.
The alignment between KHI’s mission and the development of parish communities and “the commons” is evident. Both focus on fostering resilient, self-sustaining communities that can effectively meet their own needs. KHI’s support for these efforts can further reinforce its commitment to distributism, subsidiarity, and peaceful co-existence.
8. Conclusion, Orthodox Christian Perspectives, and How Knights Hospitaller International (OBS) Can Aid
Throughout this essay, we have discussed concepts like subsidiarity, micro-banking and micro-farming networks, rejection of financialization, distributed cash for service and charitable medical clinics, parochial schools and homeschooling networks, parish communities, and an increase in “the commons.”
These practices embody Orthodox Christian values such as love of neighbor, care for the poor, stewardship of the earth, and a focus on community over individualism. They seek to address many of the problems caused by the over-centralization of resources and power in both capitalist and socialist economies, in alignment with the Orthodox Christian understanding of the fallen human tendency towards greed and oppression.
However, these practices are not without their challenges. Financial, logistical, and political barriers can hinder the implementation of these systems. Subsidiarity may struggle against entrenched power structures. Micro-banking and micro-farming networks need initial capital and continuous support. The rejection of financialization challenges established economic norms. And while distributed medical clinics, homeschooling networks, and the promotion of “the commons” can provide vital community services, they also require resources, legal support, and dedicated community members.
This is where Knights Hospitaller International (OBS) can play a pivotal role. KHI’s mission to support peace and combat corruption aligns with these principles and the organization’s wide range of capabilities make it a suitable candidate to aid in implementing them:
1. Promoting Subsidiarity: By structuring its own organization with local decision-making and leadership at the forefront, Knights Hospitaller International (OBS) sets a powerful example and helps local communities build the confidence and skills needed for self-governance.
2. Supporting Micro-Banking and Micro-Farming Networks: Knights Hospitaller International (OBS) can provide not only initial financial support but also expertise, networking opportunities, and ongoing training and support to help these ventures succeed.
3. Opposing Financialization: By advocating for fair and equitable financial systems, educating communities about predatory financial practices, and supporting alternative models, Knights Hospitaller International (OBS) can help shift the economic landscape toward Christian justice.
4. Supporting Distributed Medical Clinics and Schools: Knights Hospitaller International (OBS) can offer funding, resources, and expertise to develop these essential community services, focusing on accessibility and quality.
5. Fostering Parish Communities and “The Commons”: Knights Hospitaller International (OBS) can work closely with local Orthodox Christian parishes and other community organizations to promote shared resources and community collaboration, emphasizing the value of working together for the common good.
While the road ahead may be challenging, the vision of peaceful, resilient communities grounded in Orthodox Christian values and the principles of distributism offers a beacon of hope. KHI, in its commitment and wide range of capabilities, is well-positioned to make a significant contribution to realizing this vision.
References:
“Subsidiarity”, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. (https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/subsidiarity/)
Baogang He, “Civic Engagement through Participatory Budgeting”, Public Administration and Development. (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/pad.448)
Joanna Diane Caytas, “Developing Economies with Industrial Policy and Subsidiarity”, Columbia Journal of International Affairs. (https://jia.sipa.columbia.edu/developing-economies-industrial-policy-and-subsidiarity)
“The Cooperative Movement”, International Labour Office.
“Microfinance”, Investopedia.
“The surprising role of livestock in developing countries”, International Food Policy Research Institute.
“Financialization and Its Discontents”, Foreign Affairs.
“The Impact of Cash Transfers”, World Bank.
“Free Clinics”, American Medical Association Journal of Ethics.
“Homeschooling and the Question of Socialization Revisited”, Peabody Journal of Education.
“Parish”, Britannica.
“The City as Commons”, Journal of Peer Production.
“Parish”, Britannica.
“The City as Commons”, Journal of Peer Production.
“The Impact of Religious Schools on the Academic Achievement of Low-SES Students”, Journal of Empirical Theology.
“The Perceived Impact of Home Schooling on the Family in General and the Mother-Teacher in Particular”, Home School Researcher.
“The Role of Free Clinics in the Safety Net”, Institute of Medicine (US) Committee on the Changing Market, Managed Care, and the Future Viability of Safety Net Providers.
“Financialization: The Economics of Finance Capital Domination”, Thomas I. Palley, Springer.
“Financialization, Income Distribution, and Social Justice: U.S. Trends and European Parallels”, Jennifer Taub, Research in Political Economy.
“How Finance Is Slowly Killing the Economy”, Derek Thompson, The Atlantic. (https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/04/how-finance-is-killing-the-economy/390975/)
“The Financialization of the Economy”, CNBC. (https://www.cnbc.com/id/102424166)
“Urban Agriculture: Small, Medium, Large”, The Architectural Review. (https://www.architectural-review.com/essays/urban-agriculture-small-medium-large)
Bill Mollison, David Holmgren, “Permaculture One: A Perennial Agriculture for Human Settlements”. Transworld Publishers.
“How does permaculture contribute to food security?”, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. (http://www.fao.org/family-farming/detail/en/c/1026569/)
“Agriculture and Rural Development for Inclusive Growth and Food Security”, Asian Development Bank. (https://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/publication/151634/agriculture-rural-development-inclusive-growth.pdf)
“Microfinance and Peacebuilding”, UNDP. (https://www.undp.org/content/dam/undp/library/corporate/Development%20Studies/MicrofinancePeacebuilding.pdf)
Muhammad Yunus, “Creating a World Without Poverty: Social Business and the Future of Capitalism”. PublicAffairs.
Beatriz Armendáriz, Jonathan Morduch, “The Economics of Microfinance”, The MIT Press.
Karen Doyle Grossman, “Microfinance and Peacebuilding: Strategies for Integrating Microfinance into Peacebuilding Programs”, Master of Arts in Law and Diplomacy Thesis, Tufts University. (https://sites.tufts.edu/gmap/files/2018/04/KD-Grossman_Capstone_Final.pdf
“Distributism”, The Distributist Review.
“Orthodox Christianity and Contemporary Economics”, International Journal of Orthodox Theology.
“The Third Way: An Outline of Distributism”, Society for Distributism.
“On Wealth and Poverty”, St. John Chrysostom.
]]>